It seems that at all levels of fútbol, from the highest
international competitions, to professional leagues throughout Europe and South
America, to our own U.S. Major League Soccer, all the way down to the local recreation league, a common and
frequent complaint is about the quality of officiating. What is it that fans,
players, coaches, and anyone else involved in this game desires of an
officiating crew? In a word, it’s consistency - but, it’s tough to find.
Play-by-play and color analysts everywhere discuss this
problem with gusto, and in fairness, point out that this can be a difficult game
to call. At every level, the dive has become part of the game plan (a personal
player plan, even when it’s not part of a team strategy). The soccer referee is
trained to observe and blow the whistle a beat behind the action so that they
can measure advantage – that is, there may be a foul, but the official will
allow play to continue if the fouled team maintains a positional advantage
coming out of the foul. Protocol dictates that the referee show he is
playing advantage by reaching forward with both arms, indicating he has seen
the foul, but allowed play to continue. Advantage is difficult - of course, the fans in the stands always see it, even when the official
does not. The same goes with the off sides rule. The fans always see the off
sides call that should or should not be called – whichever best benefits their
team. Most often, an assistant referee’s call of off sides in a televised game
is proven to be correct in super slo-mo replay. Fans should be amazed that they
get it right most of the time, but we tend to remember the disallowed goal that
called, but wasn’t really off sides. Those few calls drive us crazy and the
uber fan will talk about the blown call for weeks, months, maybe even years.
There are exceptionally good referees - those that are
committed to the sport and to fair play. They take command of a match from the
outset, and do all they can to ensure that the game is decided by the play of
the athletes on the pitch; they know that people come to watch the players (not
the referee) hoping fútbol magic unfolds within the on-field-play. Great
officials take responsibility to keep the play safe, and actually help keep the
flow of the match working by controlling things tightly as the match begins.
Honestly, a great official is worth his weight in gold.
That being said, there are unfortunately, officials who do
not take control and who are not consistent in the way they call a match. This
almost invariably leads to heated interaction between the players (and
ultimately more yellow cards as the match wears on). It can mean that the game becomes
dangerous, and players end up getting injured. It is incredibly frustrating to
watch.
The Wolverines dropped their match on Oct 12th 0
- 1 against the UNLV Rebels, decided by a penalty kick. It was the kind of foul
that makes everyone cringe, and happened when a Rebel forward took the ball
into the box playing one-on-three with the UVU defense. He encountered a wall,
played the ball backwards (not towards the goal), and while turning, he tripped
over the legs of a Wolverine fullback. Yes, passe to complain about officiating
- but one observation about the center referee in the Oct 12, UNLV match: he
would not run. If an official won’t run with movement of the ball, he can’t
be in position to see what takes place as players consistently clash with one
another. In the college game, there are only three individuals who actually get
paid to run up and down the field – and those are the officials. Watch soccer
officials at all levels, the great ones make the supporting run to ensure
they are in position to see the play in front of them.
About the UNLV Game, Oct 12
UNLV has a good team – there is no question about that. The
Rebels played well, especially on their back line and through the midfield in a
match that was made more difficult by a stiff wind. UNLV controlled the play in
the first half (with the wind), and UVU controlled more of the match in the
second half (also with the wind). Ultimately, a team has to score to win and it
has proven to be a challenge for this young Wolverine team. The boys in green
consistently demonstrate that they have individual skills, but the game does
not yet look simple when they play a quality opponent. There were chances, but
too much impatience, not enough connecting interchange through the midfield and
no finish. They seemed to have trouble getting the ball to the feet of their
most dangerous players, and shots felt mistimed in this match – either rushed, or
overplayed. That doesn’t mean this team is not good – it’s overwhelmingly good,
especially as a first-year program. But, it is also inexperienced.
Seattle Redhawks, Oct 18
On Saturday evening, the Wolverines played a rematch with
the Seattle Redhawks. After a 1 – 1 tie in Orem, the match in the great
northwest ended up a 0 – 1 loss in double overtime. The match was aired on the
new WAC Digital Network, which is still working out all the kinks. The
broadcast was hampered by a digital auto focus camera that phased in and out
all night, and the audio was a mess. Despite that, it was still a benefit to be
able to watch the match.
Unfortunately, the result was tough to take. The Wolverines
have dropped five matches, by a total of five goals. Their on-field performance
in Seattle was a step above what we saw against UNLV, but still no finish. The
chances favored the Wolverines, especially in the second half, with a couple of
oh-so-close efforts. The lone (golden) goal of the game came with six minutes
remaining in the second overtime, off of a free kick from 45 yards out, played
into the box, where it bounded about and ended up in the goal. It actually
looked as though it was scored in slow motion, but nobody could stop it from
bouncing through the pipes.
It could be quite discouraging to be a part of this team and
find yourself with a 1-2-1 record in this early WAC season. On the upside –
this team has played head-to-head with teams that have years of D1 experience,
and they are not being pushed around by anyone. Their teamwork will improve.
The coaching staff clearly believes in this team, and there is a lot of season
left to play. The team is deep, and working through the normal wear and tear of
a soccer season. Expect a maximum effort this up-coming weekend when UVU
travels to the Air Force Academy and then to Kansas City, to play the UMKC
Roos.
The Wacky WAC
The old football WAC of BYU and the U of U (before the
Mountain West) was often called wacky because on any given Saturday anything
could happen. The moniker certainly applies to present day WAC Soccer. This
last week UMKC, near the bottom of the WAC standings beats UNLV sitting at the
top of the WAC. This result came in Las Vegas despite UMKC playing a man down
for thirty minutes. Houston Baptist, at the very bottom of the WAC knocked off
CSUB, near the top, Incarnate Word is now at 4-0-0 beating CUSB and San Jose,
and Air Force plays to a 0-0 tie in Phoenix against GCU. What does it all mean?
It means nobody can take a week off. It is interesting that all these upsets
came in the Sunday matches, where fatigue is most likely to play a role in the
outcome of a match.
Our next opponent, Air Force, did not look good in the first
half of their match against Grand Canyon University. It was hot in Phoenix, in
a match played in the mid afternoon. GCU had a couple a good chances in the
first 45, but could not put the ball on frame. As the second half wore on, GCU
played more and more with tired legs, and Air Force chances increased. Still,
the match ended 0-0 after 110 minutes. The standout player for Air Force
Academy was their central defender, no. 18, A. J. Esparza. (This match too was on the WAC Digital Network - I wanted to see how the Cadets were playing so I logged in to watch.)
______________________
Personal Observations
1. Cameron Kidwell, UVU’s lone senior came up limping in the
game against GCU, and hasn’t played since.
No idea on his status, but I hope he returns soon. Chandler Baddley has
played well on the back line, but Kidwell has more game experience than anyone
else on this team, the one commodity the Wolverines need.
2. My comments on and about officials does not come without
some first hand experience. If you have read my personal profile, you know that
I teach at UVU, but years ago in my 20s I was playing soccer in a state
league, coaching an under 12 competition team, and officiating the under 14s. I
only did that two seasons and I gave up coaching (more parental help then I
could handle), and officiating. The officiating went because I simply did not
have time for everything, and I wanted to play.
Still, those two years taught me a lot. I had good games,
great games, and those games where it did not matter how hard I tried, I was
constantly looking at the wrong spot – where all the action and contact seemed
to happen just out of my peripheral vision. Those were hard. As an official, I hated to call
Penalty Kicks, but would do so when it was clear-cut. I also disagreed a few
times with my assistants who waved their flags and reported fouls as they saw
them. If I felt the assistant had a better angle, I would defer to his
judgment. One time and one time only, I felt like I saw the play clearly, but my
assistant was adamant and I gave the foul. I learned then that late yellow cards came more frequently if I let early fouls slide without consequence.
As an official, I took heckling from parents – but they
weren’t standing ten feet from the play. I did the best I could and didn’t let
it bother me when I knew I was right. Usually Id' walk off f the field I feeling like I had done a good job, and
was asked both years by the completion league administration to be one of their
play-off officials.
That was years ago, but while carrying a whistle, I felt
like it was my responsibility to make the supporting run and be on top of the
play.
3. I was asked by a family member if I was trying to give advice to the coaches through this blog. I told them that anything I was able to see from the stands, or watching on-line the coaches could certainly see from the touchline. We have been a bit unlucky with a couple of our losses, and those things will even out. But, this is a game where a team makes it own luck. We are not playing poorly, but we're not getting the best of the cohesive unit either. The small things that are not working are the points emphasized everyday in training.
4. I feel good about the coming weekend. Like always, our opponents will not want to let down against the new guys, but the Wolverines will be competitive.